SAN FRANCISCO, 4:09 PM, SUN JUL 6 | 0 POSTS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS | tips@valleywag.com | RSS

Plaxo Pulse adds to our social anxiety

There's an all-new Plaxo. Fan-frickin'-tastic.In the youth culture of social networks, the worst thing to be is the old guy. Even News Corp. CEO Rupert Murdoch, after shelling out $580 million for MySpace, has tired of the website. And the Facebook frenzy could fade equally fast, if more people follow Jason Calacanis's lead and declare Facebook fatigue. That's why Plaxo has a shot — if a shaky one — at transforming itself from spammy address-book manager to the hot new thing, when it relaunches as a networking site on Monday.

Plaxo's motivations, of course, are purely mercenary. Everyone wants a piece of Facebook's magical billions. Where Facebook is weak, of course, are its not-so-private privacy settings. Your choice, when adding someone as a facebok "friend," is to offer them either an insulting (and easy to spot) "limited profile," or open the kimono, drunken party shots and all.

Plaxo, by contrast, offers more fine-tuned controls in its new Pulse social network. And, most importantly, for self-important self-promoters like podcaster Robert Scoble, it offers total control over how to spam your fans. The premise: Plaxo users will be able to designate contacts as dysfunctional family members, insincere friends, smarmy coworkers, casual acquaintances, or desperate hangers-on, and treat them accordingly — never leaving them the wiser as to their classification. Your friends will never know how limited you think they are.

If the goal is to boost its buzz, and with it the company's valuation, Plaxo's social networking bid certainly makes sense. The company's software already actively updates address books, but that's about as exciting a business as LinkedIn. The new Plaxo aims to be the Web's social butterfly. But before it emerges from the chrysalis, let's all stop and ask ourselves: Can we face the propspect of having another social network to update without going mad? At some point the old and familiar outdraws the shiny and new.

10:19 AM on Fri Aug 3 2007
By The Wag
1,125 views
6 comments

Comments

  • The Wag is back, eh?

  • Hmmm. I wonder what Sean Parker has to say about this given his role as founder of Plaxo and former President of Facebook?

  • You can selectively change privacy settings for individuals. And only on certain features. On Facebook.

  • I think that "Facebook fatigue" is going to be a very real thing. I declared that after Friendster disappeared. I have accounts on all of the social networks but setting them up, finding all your friends, etc. is just too time consuming, especially when the site will be out of style within a year and you'll have to do it all again.

    I think the future of social networking is in making the data portable.

  • it's too bad that Plaxo didn't learn the lesson from Facebook and give users the ability to turn this feature off if you want privacy. The way Pulse is configured, every one of your Plaxo contacts sees all your other activity. Nice! The party photos I uploaded for my friends also get sent to my co-workers and there is no way to prevent it. Great idea Plaxo!

  • Strangely enough, this privacy problem is exactly what Pulse was designed to solve. You can opt to share your photos with any combination of your family, friends, and business network (or nobody if you prefer). I would definitely suggest giving it another try to check out that feature, because I think that's one of the things that really makes the service work at a level above Facebook.

Start a discussion:

Reply by Email

Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.