<![CDATA[Valleywag: Arianna Huffington]]> http://cache.gawker.com/assets/base/img/thumbs140x140/valleywag.com.png <![CDATA[Valleywag: Arianna Huffington]]> http://valleywag.com/tag/arianna huffington http://valleywag.com/tag/arianna huffington <![CDATA[ Why the Huffington Post will never be Vogue ]]> Most bloggers seem to be mentally competing with the newspaper media model of The New York Times. Were they to visit the average newspaper office, they'd quickly realize what they really want: A glamorous magazine job. That seems to be Arianna Huffington's thinking, too. Gawker writer Ryan Tate has a long, delicious post about Huffington's workplace quirks. But his kicker applies to any blogging biz:

It would seem a dangerous gamble for Huffington to intentionally affect the brutality and off-the-wall demands of, say, Anna Wintour. It's not clear that a website like Huffington Post, bookmarked rather than subscribed to, will ever be able to comfortably lock in readers and advertisers like a Vogue, or to offer the same sort of glamor as a perquisite to staff.

Right on, Ryan. Owen and I have, like, 20 years of magazine work between us. If there aren't supermodels or at least Al Gore traipsing through the place daily, you're only going to drop off your boss's dry cleaning so many times.

]]>
Wed, 08 Oct 2008 10:20:00 PDT Paul Boutin http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=5060636&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ BusinessWeek scrapes Techmeme for its latest list ]]> Loic Le Meur! Gabe Rivera! Joi Ito! Don't feel bad if you've never heard of them. BusinessWeek.com's latest 25 Most Influential People on the Web is a mashup of billionaire powerbrokers with a randomized handful of those folks you run into at that same little tech conference that happens under a different name every month. I'm guessing they left out TechCrunch's Michael Arrington to create buzz. If you don't want to click through 27 pageviews on BusinessWeek's site, here's the entire list in alphabetical order:

  • Steve Ballmer
  • Mitchell Baker
  • Jeff Bezos
  • Sergey Brin, Larry Page, and Eric Schmidt
  • Jeff Clavier
  • Paul Graham
  • Arianna Huffington
  • Joi Ito
  • Steve Jobs
  • Jonathan Kaplan
  • Loic Le Meur
  • Jack Ma
  • Matt Mullenweg
  • Rupert Murdoch
  • Craig Newmark
  • Gabe Rivera
  • Kevin Rose
  • Sheryl Sandberg
  • Jon Stewart
  • Peter Thiel
  • Maria Thomas
  • Anssi Vanjoki
  • Jimmy Wales
  • Evan Williams
  • Jerry Yang

]]>
Mon, 29 Sep 2008 21:00:00 PDT Paul Boutin http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=5056554&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Even conservatives are tired of Fox hogging the debates ]]> Normally if I saw Arianna Huffington, Craig Newmark and Markos Moulitsas coauthoring a statement, I'd click my Back button and Move On, as they say. But Instapundit editor Glenn Reynolds has joined the mostly leftospheric collection of bloggers who've dubbed themselves the Open Debate Coalition. They want two things, which I've helpfully edited down to 10 words each:

1) Fox News, please let us post clips instead of threatening to sue.

2) Adopt a Digg-like voting system to let the audience choose the questions.

The first demand seems as easy as the second is sure to be rickrolled. (Photo by The Fun Times Guide)

]]>
Fri, 26 Sep 2008 11:40:00 PDT Paul Boutin http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=5055398&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ The 7 Internet women Playboy should have asked to get naked ]]> Forget the glass ceiling for a second. This week anyway, the worst enemy of "women in tech" (like we're all one big happy girl army) is the Hot List. Playboy's "Hottest Blogger" contest is still rolling, still prompting faux-thinky "conversations" about objectification and what sets women back. (An aging softcore publication is the least of our worries.) By now a couple of Playboy's nominees have confided that they're eager to lose the vote and get it over with. What, there weren't any serious "Women of the Internet" who would pose anyway? Dear Playboy: Skip the voting on the collection of contenders we've assembled. Photo-shoot them all.

Julia Allison. Because she'd actually do it. And then write everywhere about how she was totally misunderstood but it was her choice. (Photo by Nikola Tamindzic)

Cyan Banister

Cyan Banister. Even though Cyan's already bared it on Zivity, the naked lady web community she co-founded, a little mainstream exposure doesn't hurt. (Photo by Merkley)

Susannah Breslin
Susannah Breslin. Her Reverse Cowgirl blog was named as one of Time's Top 25, so she renounced sex writing. Breslin's still one of the only people blogging about sex openly unashamed to piss people off to get her story.

Zoetica Ebb
Zoetica Ebb. Zo's one of the sharp women behind Coilhouse, the alt.culture group blog that will be the nail in steampunk's grave. She may fuck you up for looking at her. You will like it. (Photo by Andrew Yoon)

Tracie Egan
Tracie Egan (Slut Machine). The spiritual leader-turned-editor of Jezebel, Gawker's dirty little sister, is the First Lady of sexual overshare. She once hired a guy to play rape her.(Photo by Nikola Tamindzic)

Marina Orlova
Marina Orlova. A philologist and YouTube queen, Marina's word origin lessons actually hold up beneath the blaze of her total power femme glamour. The Playboy audience might not make much of a dent in the 81 million views she's already got.

Ariana Huffington
Arianna Huffington. Don't say you've never thought about it. (Photo by JD Lasica)

]]>
Mon, 14 Jul 2008 12:00:00 PDT Melissa Gira Grant http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=5024465&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ HuffingtonPost going local with Chicago section ]]> The shrill cacophony of wealthy Democrats from Hollywood you've come to know and love on the Huffington Post will be coming to a major market near you soon enough, as the site will manicure content gardens for urban markets. Chicagoland bloggers now have any exciting opportunity to not get paid to contribute their opinions about local politics. [Guardian UK] (Photo by AP/Evan Agostini)

]]>
Fri, 20 Jun 2008 14:00:00 PDT Jackson West http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=5018383&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Arianna Huffington wants you to have a menage a trois ]]> Arianna Huffington"The online vs. print debate is totally obsolete. It's as musty as the old barroom argument about Ginger vs. Mary Ann. It's 2008, why not have a three-way?" — Blog mogul Arianna Huffington, putting the sin in "synergy" for BusinessWeek, 22 May 2008

]]>
Tue, 27 May 2008 16:20:00 PDT Owen Thomas http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=393524&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Who will discover Arianna Huffington's algorithim for vileness? ]]> Ariana Huffington vs. Vileness"If all those geniuses working in Silicon Valley could come up with a way to screen for those vile comments," as Arianna Huffingon mused on KQED's Forum, would her Huffington Post blog empire be empowered to delete meanness from the blogosphere? Sounds like a challenge. Maybe Google can inspire its engineers by changing its slogan to "Don't be vile."

]]>
Tue, 20 May 2008 09:20:00 PDT Melissa Gira Grant http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=391791&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ The future of Jonathan Zittrain (and how to stop it) ]]> Really, I wasn't trying to be posh for the book party Arianna Huffington threw Saturday for Oxford scholar Jonathan Zittrain and his new book, The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It." I pulled up to Larry Ellison's Pacific Heights manse in a black Town Car because that's the only vehicle I was able to flag down in North Beach. Huffington, the pundit turned blog mogul, greeted me at the door and extracted a promise of my best behavior before allowing me in. (One wonders what these people think my worst behavior might be, and if they realize how tempting living down to their expectations is.)

Stanlee Gatti, the former San Francisco arts commissioner, produced the event, which drew a crowd mixed with the Valley elite, San Francisco politicos, a gaggle of YouTubers, and oddball geek pals of Zittrain. Oh, and some grubby hacks like yours truly. Melanie Ellison, the romance novelist and wife of Oracle CEO Larry, went to high school with Zittrain, it turns out. That's the kind of it's-a-small-world connection the local press corps loves to make a big deal about. But even if Zittrain didn't have this chance connection to the Valley's movers and shakers, I'd think he'd be drawing attention from its inner circle anyway.

Speaking of which, the crowd included Chuck Phillips, the president of Oracle; Accel Partners' Jim Breyer; Google angel investor Ram Shiram; Gavin Newsom; former California governor Jerry Brown; Jessica Guynn of the Los Angeles TimesBarron's; AllThingsD's Kara Swisher; former Chronicle editor Phil Bronstein; MarketWatch's Therese Poletti; Craig Newmark; and renowned San Francisco socialite Denise Hale, who rather liked my tie.

Zittrain's book is about the tradeoffs between freedom and control, security and creativity. New devices like the iPhone provide a safer, smoother experience than the uncontrolled Web — but at the cost of having a gatekeeper, Apple, dictating what can and can't run on the device. That kind of chokepoint, in turn, makes it far easier for government regulators to get involved. The alternative, though, is not particularly attractive: an Internet ruled by spammers and hackers.

Like his counterparts in politics, Zittrain is seeking a third way. I couldn't help but think this impulse is driven by an early experience he related at the party: Getting beaten up in high school. (He thanked the hostess, Melanie, "for not beating up on me.") Having been bullied, Zittrain doesn't want revenge: He just doesn't want anyone to bully, or be bullied. This moderating impulse is seen in a passage where he discusses how neither governments nor citizens ought to be able to wholly circumvent the law through technology:

Perhaps it is best to say that neither the governor nor the governed should be able to monopolize technological tricks. We are better off without flat-out trumps that make the world the way either regulator or target wants it to be without the need for the expenditure of some effort and
cooperation from others to make it so.
If Zittrain seems like the next Lawrence Lessig, that's no coincidence. Zittrain was Lessig's teaching assistant at his first class on cyberlaw at Harvard. Stanford, Lessig's current employer, is mounting a full-court press to hire Zittrain away from Oxford and reunite the two.

And yet Zittrain's career could well exceed Lessig's. That he was able to fill a room — an impeccably furnished, tastefully modern room in one of San Francisco's wealthiest enclaves, at that — speaks to his draw. Liberal San Francisco politicans, self-made entrepreneurs, and the Web's wacky fringe can all find things they agree on in his work.

The danger for Zittrain is that his work might be nothing more than a justification for compromise and tradeoffs. Will he find a third way for the Web — or just point out the middle of the road? His calls for a "generosity of spirit" are reminiscent of the assumptions that turned eBay, a marketplace of strangers, into a very profitable community of traders. Hoping for the best really can pan out, as it happens. But the answers Zittrain will have to find, or inspire, are far more complicated than asking someone to be on their best behavior.

]]>
Mon, 12 May 2008 13:20:00 PDT Owen Thomas http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=389693&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ What's Sergey Brin doing with Arianna Huffington in Tahiti? ]]> TahitiGoogle cofounder Sergey Brin is, two days away from his company's first-quarter earnings call, sunning himself in Tahiti. As is Greco-American blog tycoon Arianna Huffington and Wendi Deng, wife of News Corp. CEO Rupert Murdoch. Huffington is reportedly there on vacation, but it's a stretch to think Brin and Deng are also there by sheer coincidence. Anyone have a bead on what prompted the South Pacific power summit? Do let us know your theories.

]]>
Tue, 15 Apr 2008 21:50:10 PDT Owen Thomas http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=380256&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Don't have a cow if you can get the milk for free ]]> Arianna HuffingtonFishbowl watch: Simon Dumenco at AdAge slams Arianna Huffington's Huffington Post a second time for not paying their bloggers. But for most of Huffington Post's celebrity contributors, a blogger's paycheck wouldn't be worth the time it would take to cash it. HuffPo seems to be doing all right, which means the real compensation for a post there is the kind of in-crowd recognition that can't be bought.

]]>
Mon, 22 Oct 2007 13:17:40 PDT Jordan Golson http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=313596&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Tech blogger on HuffPo: "Can you say IPO?" Answer: "No." ]]> ariannahuffington.jpgThe new editor at TechCrunch, Erick Schonfeld, has gotten a little IPO-crazy in these heady days of Bubble 2.0. The best guess we've seen on a Huffington Post valuation is $60 million which, for a media company, is a drop in the bucket. We can't remember a tech or media company going public with a valuation anything like that. Huffington Post is the most unlikely IPO candidate since Wired in 1996 — and Wired had substantially more revenues and a real magazine business. Maybe we were onto something with the whole cheese thing. More likely? An acquisition.

  • Yahoo News and Huffington Post have had a syndication deal since launch; buying HuffPo, as it's affectionately known, would boost Yahoo's blogger cred.
  • AOL may be looking to augment its Weblogs Inc. stable with some good political commentary. HuffPo cofounder Ken Lerer was a bigwig at AOL back in the day — though that may not help him much with Time Warner's current leadership
  • HuffPo's pseudo-namesake, the Washington Post, already has a syndication deal with them and a number of WaPo columnists blog for Huffington. The New York Times — heck, aren't they just a fancy blog already?

Really, any media company would be interested in the company that Lerer and Huffington have built — as a cheap add-on, mind you, not at a frothy IPO price. But why sell?

Even if HuffPo had any shot at an IPO — and, as Schonfeld's readers have hastened to tell him on TechCrunch's comments, it doesn't — it's not like its founders need the money. Huffington is a successful writer and got a fat divorce settlement. Lerer was a top executive at AOL and Time Warner and started his own PR firm in New York. This is their pet project and I can't see them selling anytime soon. Huffington — like Michael Moore — has world-changing aspirations. With plenty of money in her pocketbook, she doesn't have to worry about cashing out.

(Disclosure: I consulted for Huffington Post briefly in 2005.) (Photo by Amanda Edwards/Getty Images)

]]>
Tue, 02 Oct 2007 11:36:05 PDT Jordan Golson http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=306159&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Huffington Post raises more cash ]]> Arianna HuffingtonAt PaidContent, Rafat Ali picked up this interesting fact from a perfunctory USA Today profile of Arianna Huffington: Her company, The Huffington Post, has raised another $5 million in financing. With blogging companies in vogue with big media, though, that strikes me as small change. Huffington doesn't even pay most of her celebrity bloggers, so it's not clear what she would need the money for. But one wonders why she didn't take more money off the table. Could it be that, despite all the buzz, the Post's blog-for-free business model isn't all that hot?

]]>
Wed, 26 Sep 2007 09:04:02 PDT Owen Thomas http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=303869&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ TechNigga and the Don Imus of Silicon Valley ]]> loren-feldman-gaping-hole.jpg"I want to apologize to all the black tech bloggers. It could have been any ethnic group. It could have been gay guys, could have been Jews, could have been micks, skinnies, chinks, any of them...It was just your guys' bad luck that it went down that way...I'm a fucking idiot comedian and I did this." When PodTech promised to sign on more "professional producers," did it mean a white guy putting on a blackface minstrel show? Because that's what PodTech talent Loren Feldman has been up to, as part of a freakish little "opera" this videoblogger has engineered over the past week. Here's the story as told in videos, from "TechNigga" to Loren screaming, "No balls on any of you, you're just fucking sheep."

It's particularly painful to watch someone become a vicious cornered little nobody — the kind of cracked-out mess of a man that you see pushing a shopping cart and squalling at strangers — when the victim wasn't that sane to begin with. So it's not fun to write this history of Loren Feldman, who's turned himself from a mildly entertaining jester into the horrible little child you knew in grade school who would grow up beating on younger children to make himself feel powerful.

Feldman made his name in the tech blogging circle by acting out and getting sillier than anyone else dared. I loved one of his early shows, "Jason's Place," in which he parodied self-important entrepreneur Jason Calacanis by wearing a diaper and riding a hobbyhorse:

Months later, Feldman would find himself sucking up to Calacanis, pretending his startup Mahalo is more well-known than Facebook.

Once Feldman had made nice with those he previously mocked, what was left? Feldman turned to the enemies of PodTech, the company he'd mocked in the video above before they became his publisher. I'll admit it got a bit personal when he responded to my articles about the company (I've been a vocal critic of the site) by recording a puppet show with a two-year-old's ass:

But I was at least glad someone was trying to be funny. Unfortunately, Feldman has recently abandoned even this pretense.

This past Friday, Feldman posted a video titled "Where are the Black Tech Bloggers?" In this video, after explaining his question ("I mean black guys love technology. Car stereos, cell phones..."), the white male dressed as a dated caricature of a do-rag-wearing, pot-smoking black gangster hosting a site called "TechNigga."

This screw-up was particularly ironic for Feldman. A couple of months ago, he had physically threatened Guy Kawasaki, calling the entrepreneur a "stupid motherfucker" for saying he learned about selling from his Jewish friends in the jewelry industry:

Now Feldman had resorted to offending entire races. The reaction to "TechNigga" was swift and negative. Unfortunately for Feldman, black tech bloggers do exist, such as Lynne Johnson. The Fastcompany.com editor called the video "bad black face."

Feldman has recently been doing work for the Huffington Post; owner Arianna Huffington told Wired writer Adario Strange about "TechNigga," "I found it both offensive and unfunny."

The next day, Feldman posted a seemingly sincere apology to all he had recently offended in this and other videos, including tech bloggers of all races and Valleywag publisher Nick Denton and myself. He announced he would soon enter one-day sensitivity training at a rehab clinic.

But this now looks like a ruse; during his supposed treatment period, Feldman posted videos such as the following, which includes a soundtrack with the refrain, "My niggas."

Note that the more offensive videos have appeared using Blip.tv, an independent video distributor that any publisher can use without editorial permission, while the more appropriate-seeming clips use the PodTech player and appear on PodTech.net.

Feldman then apologized once more:

And released a rather funny parody of the boring gnaw-your-own-leg-off tech shows at sites like PodTech:

Before ruining everything with a final nasty strike at all who dared criticize his creative genius:

It is here that he questioned the testicular fortitude of everyone in the videoblogging community who had criticized him, as well as copping out with a "Sorry black guys, it could've been the chinks."

The obvious question is why PodTech is still in business with this insensitive, racist, bad-for-business videoblogger, and has not even criticized Feldman. The usually vocal PodTech owner John Furrier has remained silent, despite many calls for his response in a forum he frequently visits. As far as the company's behavior speaks for itself, PodTech and John Furrier apparently support Feldman's racist and hateful messages. This is one Don Imus who won't get fired.

]]>
Tue, 07 Aug 2007 16:29:15 PDT Nick Douglas http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=287091&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Arianna Huffington takes on Kevin Rose ]]> huffit.JPGArianna Huffington, personality and political blogger, continues to embrace all things new and Web 2.0 by introducing Digg-like functionality to her self-named web property, The Huffington Post, or Huffpo for short. Dubbed, unsurprisingly, HuffIt, the beta service apes Kevin Rose's voting and news aggregating service Digg. Although not a direct threat, the introduction does shed light on the challenges facing Digg.

Digg has had difficulty expanding its core market beyond tech and pop culture content while the Huffpo is popular amongst the politicos. Although there is overlapping content, the audiences are largely distinct. And Huffit is unlikely to draw a new audience; it may not even see broad adoption within its base. It mostly serves to improve the ranking of news within the existing Huffpo community. (And provide Huffington a new opportunity to brand her own name. Who else has their own verb? Trump doesn't count.)

When Kevin Rose debuted Digg, it was novel and drew upon a rabid base of geeks, but now the functionality is easy to replicate. Expanding the content and audience beyond the base is the fundamental challenge. Where does Rose find that audience if other communities can mirror Digg's features? The Digg community will not abandon the popular news aggregator, but Huffpo readers are unlikely to become diggers, they're likely to prefer "huffing" instead.

]]>
Thu, 07 Jun 2007 08:25:14 PDT Tim Faulkner http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=266827&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ An open letter to our pals at Paltalk ]]> We recently received a solicitation from video chat site Paltalk to see if we'd like to join in an interview with Amanda Congdon. Talk about a short memory. A few months back, Paltalk got in touch with Gawker for a chat with Congdon and Arianna Huffington. We cooperated, on the condition that we'd get to run a highlight clip on Gawker. Unfortunately (for us), things did not go as planned. First, we asked for reader queries, and received the expected raft of obscenity and foolishness. There were a few gems, which we dutifully compiled for use. However, we'd have to settle for just Arianna, as Amanda, now on West Coast time, wouldn't be interviewed until the New York staff was well into the second half of happy hour. So fine, Huffington solo.

Paltalk prez Joel Smernoff showed up at Gawker HQ to set up the video feed, and our own Intern Heather (now Editorial Assistant Heather) asked the questions. By all accounts, Huffington handled even the coarsest questions with characteristic aplomb, and all present were dutifully amused. You'll never know though, because after a day of silence, Smernoff finally responded to our "where's the damn clip" emails:
Thanks for reaching out to us and glad that Gawker was able to participate in the live chat with Arianna yesterday. Unfortunately, after discussing this with counsel and given the relationship with Huffington Post, they are uncomfortable with releasing any of the proprietary video from the chat for external purposes at this time.
"Reaching out"? You contacted us, pal(talk). Never had I been date-raped for content with such careless poise. We obviously shouldn't have let him leave the office alive without surrendering the clip first. Further questions about what was meant by "the relationship with Huffington Post" went unanswered. We asked Arianna herself what that might mean, and she had no idea.

So, to Mr. Philip V. Ramirez at GroupGordon Strategic Communications: Thanks for "reaching out" to us for the Amanda Congdon interview. Unfortunately, after discussing this with what little dignity you left us last time, we are uncomfortable with releasing anything to you other than proprietary feces produced precisely for such external purposes. At this time. ]]>
Fri, 09 Feb 2007 13:24:24 PST Chris Mohney http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=235513&view=rss&microfeed=true
<![CDATA[ Geek out: Al Gore lunges and Martha befriends a topless boy at D Conference ]]> Wrap up the Powerbook cord and follow Esther Dyson to the next con — the D Conference winds down today. For actual news from people who are there, check out the Wall Street Journal's blog. (Favorite post: Turning the schmaltz up to 11.) For trumped-up news filtered through the snark machine, look no further. Photos by ZDNet reporter Dan Farber.


It's every boy's wet dream: get topless with Martha Stewart. At any rate, that guy in the shades looks jealous.

Walt Mossberg, Kara Swisher, Al Gore - Valleywag
Al Gore, confused by the scenery, spent the whole time asking when the shuttle would blast off.

Wubby - Valleywag
"I never attend a conference without my Wubby."

Someone important, surely - Valleywag
J. Peterman: "Elaine, you may call it Myanmar, but it will always be Burma to me."

Three schmoozers - Valleywag
"Ahahahaha, ahaha, aha...yes, yes, I am the love child of Steve Rubel and Tucker Carlson."

Al Gore - Valleywag
After host Kara Swisher was pried out from under the statesman's body, Mossberg wrote, "Lesson Learned: Don't offer Al Gore cake."

Someone and Renee Blodgett - Valleywag
My god, Blodgett, you don't have to say yes to every conference invite.

Esther and Al - Valleywag
Sandwiched between Al Gore and a big techie journalisty guy, Esther Dyson can't help but make an "I am cute and tiny!" face.

Smiles held one second too long - Valleywag
A moment of silence for the Guy Who Forgot to Bring Collared Shirts. (Don't be that guy.)

Arianna Huffington - Valleywag
"No," says blog publisher Arianna Huffington, "I don't have any spare change. Now move away, you're standing in front of my Prius."

Execs on stage - Valleywag
Walt Mossberg: "Whatever you do, let's please not make Marissa Mayer giggle."

Photos: D Conference [Dan Farber on Flickr]

]]>
Thu, 01 Jun 2006 19:59:01 PDT Nick Douglas http://valleywag.com/index.php?op=postcommentfeed&postId=177863&view=rss&microfeed=true