Is Nick Denton going soft? Even his cutbacks are sentimental these days. In the old days, Denton, the publisher of Valleywag and 14 other Gawker Media blogs, would simply shutter blogs. These days, he worries first about finding them nice homes. Such is the velvet-glove treatment he's giving Gridskipper, Wonkette, and Idolator, his blogs about, respectively, travel, politics, and music. The three blogs amount to less than 3 percent of Gawker Media's traffic, he says. Fine, so why keep them around in any form? Silicon Alley Insider has the details on their new owners. More evidence of Denton's increasing namby-pambosity: Instead of threatening to fire leakers, he's encouraging us to post the internal memo announcing the move. Darling bossman, that's no fun. But also no reason to keep the memo from you, dear readers:
Nick DentonMon, Apr 14, 2008 at 7:26 AM I'm amazed we've managed to keep a lid on this news; that, given your naturally gossipy natures, must be a first! We're spinning off three sites: Idolator, Gridskipper and—this one may be a surprise—Wonkette. There were indeed some rumors about Maura Johnston's music blog late last year; they were true of course. For reasons that I'll explain below, both it and our travel and politics sites have better commercial futures outside Gawker than within. (Excuse the corporate lingo: some of it is unavoidable.) But, first, the facts, which will be hitting the wires later this morning, or as soon as you leak this email. Go ahead!
* IDOLATOR is going to Buzznet, a music-focused web and social network. Buzznet recently acquired Idolator's chief rival, Stereogum, and received a big investment from Universal Music Group. * GRIDSKIPPER isn't going far: it's being taken over by Curbed, the network founded by Lockhart Steele, in which Gawker Media is a shareholder. * WONKETTE is being spun off to the managing editor, Ken Layne, former founder of one of the web's very first news sites, Tabloid.net. The title will become part of the Blogads network of political sites, which includes Daily Kos, among others.
Why these three sites? To be blunt: they each had their editorial successes; but someone else will have better luck selling the advertising than we did.
Music audiences are fragmented across genres; Maura's Idolator gave Stereogum a good run, but a group with a whole array of music sites will command more attention from record labels than we could. In the case of Gridskipper, our urban travel guide, we could never match Curbed in attention to city-specific content and advertising. As for Wonkette: political advertisers are a strange breed; they don't come through the same agencies our sales people deal with.
I'm relieved we've found pretty decent homes for the three sites, and most of their writers, but we're gutted to lose them. Idolator's Pop Critic's Poll was a tremendous coup—and Patric's bleeding-heart logo for the site was one of my favorites. Gridskipper is so far the most sophisticated travel blog: it entirely deserved its inclusion in Time's list of the 50 coolest websites.
And Wonkette is one of the brands with which the company is most associated; people will be shocked that we would ever part with it. The political site has won an array of Bloggies and other awards; it introduced the word ass-fucking into the dictionary of political abuse; the founding editor's slippers are even on display in the new media museum in Washington, DC. And Ken and his team have brought a new liveliness to the site this election season—validated by the record traffic of the last three months.
So why not wait, at least till the election? Well, since the end of last year, we've been expecting a downturn. Scratch that: since the middle of 2006, when we sold off Screenhead, shuttered Sploid and declared we were "hunkering down", we've been waiting for the internet bubble to burst. No, really, this time. And, even if not, better safe than sorry; and better too early than too late.
Everybody says that the internet is special; that advertising is still moving away from print and TV; and Gawker sites are still growing in traffic by about 90% a year, way faster than the web as a whole. But it would be naive to think that we can merely power through an advertising recession. We need to concentrate our energies, and the time of Chris Batty's sales group, on the sites with the greatest potential for audience and advertising.
The dozen sites that remain represent some 97% or our 228m pageviews per month, and an even higher proportion of our growth and advertising revenue. (Key facts are below, in case anyone asks.) We'll be able to devote more attention to breakouts such as Jezebel and io9, as well as established titles such as Gizmodo and Kotaku, which are becoming utterly dominant in their domains. And, then, once this recession is done with, and we come up from the bunker to survey the internet wasteland around us, we can decide on what new territories we want to colonize.
Both Noah and I are around to answer any questions. On email, IM, or phone. I'm 917-XXX-XXXX and Noah is on 917-XXX-XXXX.
Regards
Nick
—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—-—
GAWKER MEDIA KEY FACTS
* A dozen sites, Gizmodo first launched in August 2002, most recent,
io9, in January 2008
* Gawker, Gizmodo, Kotaku, Lifehacker, Jalopnik, Deadspin, Defamer,
Jezebel, Valleywag, io9, Consumerist, Fleshbot
* A record 18 "Bloggie" nominations in 2008, way more than any other
blog collective (one of those was for Idolator)
* Audience of 29.7m unique visitors a month for the whole network, up
82% at annualized rate (http://www.quantcast.com/p-d4P3FpSypJrlA)
* Each individual site has at least 1m uniques or, in the case of io9, soon will
* Pageviews of 227m in March — 219m if you take out the three sites
being spun out — up 89% on a year earlier (Sitemeter)
* For those who measure these things, Gawker is the web's leading
independent blog group










Comments
Is VW next?? The only gawker blog that matters is Gizmodo.
I am a big Gridskipper fan as much for the graphical presentations as the urban travel. I hope you have good travels and I will clicking in. Truly best to you all.
Ken Layne: This is my way of sticking it to The Man.
SAS: But, Sir--you are The Man.
Ken Layne: Precisely.
Any chance of Sploid getting resurrected under a new owner?
@Smitros: Nah, we're keeping Sploid for a future project.
@ballmer: Depends on lots of things.
How well does the ad market keep with for the Valleywag demographic?
Does Valleywag keep growing?
Can Denton find a buyer? The blogs he sold were some of the least niche blogs that Gawker owns.
Does Denton still have a soft spot in that hard heart of his for Valleywag? He has quite a history with this gossip rag.
Or you could go ask him. [www.nickdenton.org]
Denton wanted to sell me Valleywag, but I had used all my pocket change on the parking meter.
no offense mike, but i find your site to be tedious, poorly written and boring, i can't remember the last time i read it, whereas i have to ween myself from wasting my entire day on valleywag.
@Nick Denton: Haven't seen you grace us with your presence at Valleywag for a long time, but I'm still waiting for those "snarky comments" you promised.
@Nick Denton: I want in on that, dammit.
Why on earth would you unload your best-known name brand, Wonkette? That doesn't really make any sense.
I love Idolator and hope it gets more attention.
@Hot Foot: in this game, doesn't web traffic trump quality?
@ballmer - hello, Lifehacker? That site is the best of the bunch.
>>she says as a former Lifehacker editor<<
Too insidery.
You redact his phone numbers, but not others? Come on - level playing field.
@Michael Arrington: Hey, everybody has been expecting the grand roll-up ever since you hired Heather. I don't see it happening. Certainly don't see it sticking. And, without a roll-up, you have a niche Valley site with some 3% of the traffic of Gawker or Weblogs Inc. Good luck with that when the tech bubble bursts!
Nick has to make room for the upcoming all-Julia Allison site, trainwreckr
@Catbirdseat: FTW!
I would so never read that.
I'm of the mindset that if they were any good, I would be reading them. Since I don't read any of them, fuck em. Seems logical....
@ballmer: I would imagine Lifehacker and Kotaku do well.
@Nick Denton: Do you really think that's Michael Arrington? I doubt it, unless he's had one of his "insecurity" episodes. The reason I appreciate Valleywag is because for years tech was the only industry to not have a publication covering the underbelly of it. What Techcrunch does is done by roughly 8 other websites, and half of the content is the parsing of readily available PR statements.
I would suspect his revenue stream with the highest profit-margin are actually those little start-up parties he throws, and as soon as that well runs dry I desperately hope he shitcans Duncan Riley.
Awesome. This is the cat fight I came to see.
Who said Sploid? I want in!
@belltolls: Agreed. Definitely happy to see it going to Curbed.
@Nick Denton:
Sweet. Thank you, and let me know if I can help.
idolator and wonkette were among my favorites; hoping they find happy homes elsewhere.
Wonkette was cool from the giddyup. Sorry to see it ride to a new ranch.
Idolator, on the other hand, wasn't really funny. And if u'r not funny u'r nuthin' on the internets...
But I really can't wait to pull out my Esty-made Sploid T-Shirt again. Something to look forward to this summer.
@Jeremy: What, you don't already have them? That totally blows my image of your professional talents.
@Nick Denton: The closest things I see to a bubble in tech, right now, are the valuations. The problem is that there's such low liquidity in the web 2.0 arena that the prices don't mean anything.
Too many people have been saying "bubble" for too long for a tech bubble to form. What we're seeing now is people looking at VC investments with questionable business models and WebVan fresh in their minds.
Maybe another idea would be to hire better sales people?
@brechtgirl: Yes, to which Valleywag completely crushes Arrington's glorified PR release aggregator.
Great, now I have to take Wonkette out of my "Gawker" bookmark folder. You'll pay for this inconvenience, Denton!
Wonkette was lost with the head Wonker moved on. It's almost like what will happen to Deadspin if/when Will decides to write more for the big papers. They have a nice core, but it depends on a good editor to keep it flowing.
While I love many of the Gawker Empire, I found Idolator to be incredibly self-indulgent, and horribly so. But then again, every music blog seems to be extremely pretentious. sigh.
@metallicmeatloaf: Oh, don't do that. Ken's brilliant, one of my favorite writers on the web. And, now that he's writing for himself, you can expect even more energy.
Idolator is pretty awful. Between their obsession with loving and hating american idol and their abhorrence for Vampire Weekend, it was getting impossible to read a worthwhile story.
@Rabbi Dave: What a silly thing to say! The best sales people focus on the most lucrative of prospects. Which is why it's hard to attract salespeople to political media. Witness the problems of Huffpo. Henry Copeland at Blogads has done a better job in that arena than anybody.
Off to Idolator's new home.
It's been fun, gawker.
Nick, nice to see you're not closing blogs these days and appreciate the value in letting them live on, be it in someone else's hands
If it comes to _what really matters to Nick, lines like these sound bad for the future of VW:
_they each had their editorial successes; but someone else will have better luck selling the advertising than we did_
What advertising has there been on VW?
When Nick himself was active emiritus, we saw Logitech ads, afterwards there were American App. ads and now, now there are Gawker artist ads. Luckily überlord Denton has a weak spot for VW and I'm still looking forward to a VW spinoff focused on blogging.
Nick, maybe you should hire Duncan as an editor. Fun guaranteed and I'm sure there would be quite some traffic... Duncan+Denton's forces combined.
Sounds like a winner to me! And why not subvention that new sites via Gizmodo and Gawker ads!?
Oh well, no blog family is ever happy.
And I think some more axing needs to be done. Defamer and Gawker need to merge on the double, I think.
@RavingRabbid: wrong coasts
valleywag's the only gawker blog I read, I'd hate to ever see it go
Start a discussion:
Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?