The latest flaming bomb from Mac blogger John Gruber: "How Leander Kahney Got Everything Wrong by Being a Fucking Jackass." Kahney's sin? Writing Wired's latest cover story, ""How Apple Got Everything Right by Doing Everything Wrong." Kahney's thesis: Apple succeeds despite violating Google's "don't be evil" rules of business. Gruber's response? Name-calling, starting in the headline. Gruber attacks with stabbing frenzy:
The whole contrast-with-Google angle makes no sense, holds up to no scrutiny, and serves no purpose other than to reach the punchy conclusion that Apple is "irredeemably evil." By Kahney's logic, any company that is different from Google —- and clearly most companies are far more different from Google than Apple is —- is evil.
It's a dull knife. Gruber's argument, not Kahney's, founders on its specifics. When Kahney calls Jobs a "notorious micromanager," Gruber retorts that Google VP Marissa Mayer approves every minor change to the Google homepage. There's no comparison: Jobs is a screaming jerk who wouldn't last one minute in the cuddly Googleplex. Gruber's real argument, I suspect, is that he should be writing cover stories for Wired. John, why don't you just pitch Chris Anderson directly? That seems easier.
(Photo by Randy Stewart)







Comments
That wooshing sound you just heard was Jordan missing the point.
Somebody remind me why I'm supposed to care what one of Borat's cousins think.
That sucking sound you hear is Cupertino making yet another crappy laptop.
FASHION POLICE!
Can someone please shuttup Daring Futzball?
It's kind of sad for Gruber. It's like he feels the need to vigorously defend the cool kid in the room against the snide mumblings of a bunch of rattled nerds. John, the cool kid really doesn't give a shit about you or those detractors you spend your days shooting down...
I love how people can go from being nobody's to somebody overnight. Life is grand in the US. what does this guy do anyway that I care who he insults.
@w00zy33: I only care about his career path that led to being quoted here. But yeah.
@w00zy33: You didn't just read the article, you commented on it.
Who is he? He's an irritating, smug and incredibly anally retentive defender of Apple and (almost) all it does. I can't recommend his blog highly enough. Seriously. Insight of the kind you seldom find on Valleywag.
@raincoaster: He did some web development stuff for a bit while writing his blog. His blog got popular enough that it's now his fulltime job.
Actually, DF regularly captures nuggets of insight that cross technology, media, design, etc. There are so many bloggers basically re-framing the same picture over and over, that the goodness of a fresh perspective shouldn't be under-valued.
Specific to the Wired article, his point was actually dead on. The real story is less about how Apple and Google are so different and more about how they are without peer in successfully navigating and collapsing the once impenetrable barriers between the PC, mobile, media and internet spaces.
I dub Apple and Google, 'The Chess Masters' and see them on an inevitable collision course given their mammoth ambitions.
Here is my post on the topic: [thenetworkgarden.com]
Cheers,
Mark
I look forward to DF everyday. Great window into the stuff I'm interested in. He is a n Apple apologist, but does try to show all sides of the argument. I'd never been to Valleywag until he linked to you today. I doubt he wants to write for you.
I look forward to DF everyday. Valuable insights and a window in to many things I'm interested in. I had never been to valleywag until he linked to you today. I doubt he would want to write for you.
Gruber's blog is one of the ONLY ones I read daily, because like him or agree with him, he writes to his own beat. People get their panties in a knot because he chose some expletives. So what? Who has not thought of someone as a fucking jackass on occasion? Gruber just had the stones to write it. Deal. I subscribed to Wired for years. I don't any more. To many articles written by fucking jackasses.
I must be missing something. Why would Gruber want to demote himself to write for a kids mag ... when he has that fine column all by himself?
Comment on this post
Reply by EmailLogin with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?